Stone
is one of the earliest building materials. It is surprising that stone almost
requires no special manufacturing processes and is so durable that stone
structures built thousands of years ago are still used today!! (Very few
contemporary “green” products may act the same in this case). Besides from
that, stone has all the attributes of a green product. It requires almost no
chemicals to produce or maintain, it emits no VOCs or hazardous airborne
pollutants, and it is water-resistant. In areas with large temperature
fluctuations, stone can play the role of a thermal mass. Also some stone even
has good solar reflectance. Concerning biophilia concept, as buildings that
connect people with nature, it is fair to mention the universal attraction of
natural materials like stone. The truth is that stone is most natural material
used by human being in the first place to accommodate our ancestors.
A
life-cycle assessment (LCA) of granite and limestone claddings has shown that
granite cladding compared to brick and mortar, precast concrete, and aluminum
had the least detrimental environmental profile, followed by limestone, then
brick (a virtual tie), and aluminum. In case of embodied carbon, sandstone,
granite, and marble have lower amount than brick, timber, and steel (University
of Bath’s ICE).
By
comparing stone quarrying to a modest forestry operation, we can understand
that the deteriorating habitat impacts are much less than logging and milling
wood. Even the amount of site disturbance and soil and habitat loss from
forestry operations far exceeds that of quarrying.
Stones
that have not been crushed, called dimension stone, can be used as flooring,
exterior cladding, solid surfaces, and interior walls, as well as for
landscaping and many other applications. Moreover, the crushed stone can also
be used in many other industries (concrete, asphalt, landscape, etc.) and this
reduces its leftover.
Of
the estimated 1.88 million tons of dimension stone produced in the U.S. in
2011, approximately 43% were used by the building industry. (For comparison,
this figure is about 20% out of 95.6 million tons of total produced raw steel).
Roughly half of the total U.S. stone market is imported from Brazil, China,
India, Italy, and some other countries.
Stone
Types and Uses
The
primary types of dimension stone sold today are granite, limestone, marble,
slate, and sandstone. (There are many others, including basalt, soapstone, and
quartzite, etc.)
Different quarries have different looks. Therefore, for designers and architects that search for a specific stone color or type, purchasing locally can be very difficult. Hence, the route that stone takes from processing to site can vary from a few miles to thousands of miles! Moreover, there are some stones that are imported from Brazil or another country and sent to Italy or China for processing before being sent to the U.S. Even stone quarried in the U.S. is regularly sent oversees for processing and then sent back to the U.S. This obviously wasteful practice is due to lower overseas labor costs. For sure, transporting stone from quarry to jobsite does have a negative environmental impact due to the need for heavy equipment and trucks transportation. A study of embodied carbon and natural stone shows that transportation is the main contributor of embodied carbon in stone. However, by considering the long service life of stone and its durability, those transportation impacts may not be quite as significant (in a 100-plus-year lifespan).
A
major problem involved with stone is that tracking it from an extraction quarry
to its final market can be nearly impossible since just like a commodity, both
imported and domestic stone are often sent across the globe and may be
processed elsewhere. This makes third party verification system unable to
properly judge about some related issues.
There
is a misunderstanding problem with stone quarrying. In fact, many people don’t
distinguish between quarrying and mining. In mining a lot more material is
taken out of mines than in quarrying. For example, in order to produce 1 pound
copper, about 143 pounds of rock is needed. Furthermore, stone comes from rock
which is at the surface and even at the end of a quarry’s production; the
obtained area might be usable land in some cases (i.e. proper for lakes).
The
point is although stone is not the greenest material or a complete one; it is
close to some best materials that are considered sustainable. Most of the
problems of applying it in construction industry are manageable. Therefore, it
is essential to increase its valuable functionality in common belief by
conducting some more well-organized researches in this case.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteStone is in fact a very durable material. Its just that the labor and time time is a significant tradeoff. Hiring of a stone mason is sort of rare as well as the material's availability. Ordering stone internationally is expensive, too. I don't think the construction industry think about it's sustainable value but the rather the reasoning for using a such a medium compared to contemporary construction material.
ReplyDelete